A guide to choosing well

Compare
decking
materials.

Four premium decking options. One is logged from the Amazon, one is plastic, one crosses two oceans to reach a chemical plant. Only black locust grows here.

Black locust decking and landscaped steps beside a residential swimming pool
Made for life outdoors.Black locust · Residential pool deck
View project
1,700 lbfJanka hardness, harder than oak
50 yearsLimited warranty
No treatmentNaturally rot resistant
AppalachianGrown and milled in the U.S.
The lineup

Four materials.
Only one grows here.

Ipe is cut from the Amazon rainforest. Accoya is New Zealand pine soaked in chemicals at a plant overseas. Composite is plastic. Black locust grows in the Appalachians and goes into your deck with nothing added.

Tropical hardwood

Ipe

Cut from the Amazon. Most traded ipe comes from deforestation hotspots, and up to 75% from Pará may be logged illegally.

Origin
Brazilian Amazon
Treatment
None
Janka hardness
~3,600 lbf
Modified softwood

Accoya

Plantation pine from New Zealand, shipped to a chemical plant to be soaked in acetic anhydride, then shipped again to reach you.

Origin
New Zealand + Netherlands
Treatment
Acetylation
Janka hardness
~920 lbf
Plastic decking

Composite / PVC

Plastic boards, often mixed with wood flour. They run hot in the sun, and as they weather they shed microplastic particles.

Origin
Plastic factory
Treatment
Plastic & additives
Janka hardness
Not comparable
Full comparison

Every material, every factor

A practical overview of four premium decking choices. Ratings are editorial assessments; service life and performance depend on product, installation, climate and care.

Swipe horizontally to explore all factors

Decking material comparison: lifespan, hardness, maintenance, heat, treatment, origin and relative cost.
MaterialLifespanHardnessUpkeepHeat underfootTreatmentSourcingCost
Black locustDomestic hardwood
50+ yearsGround-contact durable; used for fence posts for centuries
1,700 lbfHarder than white oak and teak
None requiredWeathers to silver; oil optional for color
Wood-coolNatural wood sheds heat instead of storing it
NoneRot resistance is in the wood itself
Appalachian U.S.Fast-growing native tree, about 40 years to harvest
$$$$Moderate
IpeTropical hardwood
30+ yearsNaturally rot resistant
~3,600 lbfVery hard; must be pre-drilled
Oil yearly for colorEnd-seal to limit checking
Wood-coolDense, but cooler than plastic
NoneNaturally durable
Brazilian AmazonSlow-growing; high illegal-logging risk
$$$$Expensive
AccoyaAcetylated radiata pine
50-yr warrantyAbove ground; 25 years in ground contact
~920 lbfA softwood; dents more easily
LowCoatings only for color
Wood-coolNatural wood fiber
AcetylationFactory chemical modification
Plantation pineLargely New Zealand pine, modified in a chemical plant
$$$$Expensive
Composite / PVCPlastic & wood fiber
20+ yearsSurface fades and scratches; can't be sanded
Not ratedPlastic flexes; needs tighter joist spacing
Wash for moldNo preservative finish, but mildew needs regular cleaning
Hot in sun140–165°F in full sun; dark colors worst
PlasticPetroleum-based; hard to recycle
Factory-madePlastics and additives
$$$$–$$$$Wide range
Ratings 1 to 5, higher is betterCost column: relative price tier, not a quote
Heat underfoot

Made for summer.
Mindful of the heat.

Surface temperature matters beside a pool or on a sunny terrace. In full summer sun, composite boards measure 140°F and up, and dark colors reach 150 to 165°F. In one side-by-side test in Florida, natural hardwood stayed around 120°F, 20 degrees or more cooler.

Material, color, exposure and weather all affect surface heat. All decking, including natural wood, can become too hot for bare feet. Compare specific products and plan for shade where comfort matters most.

No plastic

Black locust is solid wood, all the way through.

Plan for shade

Comfort depends on the whole outdoor space.

Sources: Advantage Lumber infrared test, Sarasota, FL; Ask the Builder thermal camera reading (152°F on a composite step); contractor field readings for dark composite (150–165°F).

Head to head

A closer look at
the closest alternatives.

Black locust
vs
Ipe
  • Ipe is harder, but 1,700 lbf is already harder than oak or teak.
  • Black locust grows here; ipe is cut from the Amazon, where most of the trade comes from deforestation hotspots.
  • Both last decades without chemicals. Black locust costs less.

Installing ipe: pre-drill every screw, carbide blades, 316 stainless fasteners, an N95 mask for the dust, and a week or two of acclimation on site.

Read the full comparison →
Black locust
vs
Accoya
  • Accoya is pine made durable in a factory; black locust is durable as it grows.
  • Black locust is nearly twice as hard (1,700 vs ~920 lbf).
  • Accoya crosses two oceans and a chemical plant to reach New York. Black locust travels a few hundred miles by truck.
Read the full comparison →
Black locust
vs
Composite
  • Composite is plastic. As it weathers it sheds microplastic particles into your yard.
  • Scratches and fading on composite are permanent. Wood can be sanded and oiled.
  • In full sun it runs 20°F or more hotter than natural wood; dark boards reach 150 to 165°F.
  • Both are low-maintenance. Only one is a real wood deck.
See the heat test →
Where it comes from

Rainforest, plastic,
or the forest next door.

Every alternative to black locust carries a cost before it reaches your deck. Ipe is cut from the Amazon. Accoya crosses two oceans and stops at a chemical plant. Composite starts as plastic. Black locust grows a few hundred miles from New York. Watch each route play out.

New ZealandArnhem, NLPará, BrazilPanama CanalYour project (NYC)
Your projectChemical modification
    ~200miles from forest to a New York deck

    Miles traveled before it reaches a New York deck

    Straight-line distance between stops. Ships and trucks travel farther.
    Accoya
    ~15,000
    Ipe
    ~3,300
    Black locust
    ~200
    Ipe · Deforestation80%+

    of traded ipe comes from 20 Amazon municipalities that are deforestation hotspots.

    Mongabay, 2022
    Composite · PlasticPlastic

    Composite boards are made with plastic. As they weather in sun and rain, they shed microplastic particles into your yard.

    Latvian State Institute of Wood Chemistry
    Accoya · Distance75×

    farther traveled than black locust to reach the same New York deck, by way of a chemical plant in the Netherlands.

    Straight-line distance between stops
    Black locust · Local0

    chemicals, plastics or rainforest. Grown in the Appalachians, milled at our sawmill, trucked to your project.

    ~200 miles to New York City
    Black locust trees in bloom
    From our forests, to your project

    Good material starts
    at the source.

    Black locust brings natural durability and a domestic supply chain to exterior projects. From forest to sawmill, its origin is part of what you specify.

    Explore our approach ↗
    In the field

    Real spaces.
    Lasting impressions.

    Black locust covered terrace at Phipps Conservatory in Pittsburgh
    Phipps ConservatoryCovered terrace · Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
    Black locust beachfront deck at The BodyHoliday in Saint Lucia
    The BodyHolidayBeachfront decking · Saint Lucia
    Black locust porch on a stone estate near Philadelphia
    Solar Roof EstateCovered porch · Philadelphia area
    Before you decide

    A few more
    things to know.

    Good questions lead to a better specification.

    Which decking material is right for my project?

    Start with exposure, traffic and appearance, then ask where the boards come from. If you want a hard, long-lasting deck without rainforest timber, plastic or chemical treatment, black locust is the one that checks every box.

    Does black locust decking need oil or sealer?

    A preservative coating is not required for black locust’s natural rot resistance. Left unfinished, it weathers toward silver-gray. An appropriate finish can help retain its warmer color. Routine cleaning and installation care still matter.

    Can Janka hardness be used to compare composite and wood?

    Janka is a wood indentation test. Composite and PVC products use different performance tests, so an unrated composite is not a zero-hardness material. Compare manufacturer specifications for the intended application.

    Why does it matter where decking comes from?

    Most ipe is logged in the Amazon, where the trade is tied to deforestation hotspots and widespread illegal logging. Accoya is pine from New Zealand that crosses oceans and goes through a chemical plant. Composite is plastic that sheds microplastics as it weathers. Black locust grows in the Appalachians and reaches East Coast projects by truck.

    See it, feel it

    The next step?
    Hold it in your hands.

    See the grain. Feel the weight. Put black locust alongside your other options and choose your next deck with confidence.

    Sources, methodology & comparison notes

    Published by Black Locust Lumber, a supplier of one of the materials compared. Ratings reflect editorial judgments. Prices and product specifications vary; confirm current manufacturer documentation before specifying. All material types require routine cleaning and proper installation.

    Black locust and ipe figures: Black Locust Lumber. Accoya: McIlvain Accoya specifications (Janka 922 lbf; 50-year above-ground / 25-year ground-contact warranty).

    Ipe weight, hardness and installation: McIlvain ipe decking guide; e-architect, Specifying ipe. Accoya sourcing and processing: AVEVA; Green Building Advisor. Distances are straight-line between stops. Composite movement and mold: EnviroBuild.

    Heat: Ask the Builder, Temperature of Composite Decking; Fence & Deck Supply, composite color and heat; Advantage Lumber, Composite vs. PVC vs. Hardwood for Full Sun.

    Ipe and deforestation: Mongabay (2022); Forest Trends (2022); Chalmers University study, reported by Wood Floor Business (2023); CITES implementation for ipe (ATIBT). Composite microplastics: Latvian State Institute of Wood Chemistry.

    OUR SAWMILL

    Black Locust Products

    Black Locust Lumber is a fully integrated sawmill in central Pennsylvania,  supplying Black Locust products throughout the United States and Canada.
    Black Locust Lumber

    Our Portfolio